Homework5 Hayden

Analyze This Document
The document shows a new publisher would like to participate in a book seller's show, but the document has some improper usages. The following are the strengths an the weakness of each sentence.

Sentence1
Strength: Using plain English.
Weakness: We may think the writer wants to sell his books, but actually he wants to ask the cost for attending the book exhibition.

Sentence2
Strength: Emphasizing the positive. It is good to let the reader know his announcement in Publishers Weekly is effective.
Weakness: Giving unnecessary details. I think "…you're having this summer" can be omitted. The word "show" is generalized. We do not know it is a exhibition or something.

Sentence3
Strength: Powerful. Make writer close to reader.
Weakness: Lack of etiquette. Oral language is not proper in writing.

Sentence4
Strength: Clear idea.
Weakness: Lack of reader's benefit. It only talks about writer's interest.

Sentence5
Strength: The writer knows how to promote his books, and lets readers know he takes the exhibition seriously.
Weakness: The writer still only cares about his own interest.

Sentence6
Strength: The writer uses his experience to enhance his technique in airbrushing.
Weakness: This sentence is not really related to writer's purpose of the letter.

Sentence7
Strength: Provide writer's capability in sign painting.
Weakness: It is also irrelevant to writer's purpose of the letter. The sentence at the end of the paragraph should be powerful to repeat writer's purpose.

Sentence8
Strength: The writer gives other information to show he has strategies to advertise his books.
Weakness: It seems the writer is boastful. It may drag reader's attention and make reader confused why the writer wants to attend the exhibition.

Sentence9
Strength: The writer is thoughtful to let reader share his publicity.
Weakness: The tone is arrogant and it may let reader feel uncomfortable.

Sentence10
Strength: Purposeful.
Weakness: Reader may think the writer really cares about cost for booth space, and does not pay much attention on exhibition.

Revised Document

Dear Sirs,

As a new publisher, I would like to know the costs of renting booth space because I am interested in attending your book exhibition. I think your book exhibition gives me a big chance to promote my two books, T-shirt Art and How to Make Money in the Sign Painting Business. I was an airbrush artist before, so I hope that I can use these techniques to advertise my books and I think that it also can make your exhibition lively.

Your book exhibition really can do me a big favor. I look forward to your response and hope you give me more details about the exhibition.

Yours sincerely,
Hayden Lively.

Homework 5 49482012 Sandra

Homework 5 49482012 陳亭縈

Analyze This Document

According to the content, the writer is an airbrush artist who wants to attend a bookseller's exhibition and promote his books. He writes a letter to the sponsor in order to deliver his willingness of attending the activity. However, there are several errors in this letter. The most obvious one is that the writer only use "you" point to compose his letter. The following are analyses to each sentence and the revised document.

Sentence 1:

Weakness: The writer shows too much confidence by using the phrase "really great books". It may leave the sponsor a bad impression. In addition, the writer's words are abstract and pompous. He doesn't build a strong relationship with his reader in the beginning. Besides, the writer doesn't start with his main idea. He wants to attend to exhibition and promote his airbrush techniques instead of selling books.

Sentence 2:

Weakness: The first error is that the writer should use "exhibition" instead of "show" in his letter. Using imprecise words may confuse the reader. The second one is that the sentence "I think it's a great idea" is informal. The writer should convey his admiration in more polite way.

Sentence 3:

Weakness: It is inappropriate to use buzzwords, such as folks, in a business letter. The reader may consider the writer is not professional.

Sentence 4:

Strength: The writer uses "I would like" to show his politeness and request to the sponsor.

Weakness: It is weird to say "to get some space to show my books". Actually, it doesn't precisely deliver the writer's main idea which is to participate in the bookseller's exhibition. It sounds like the writer just needs a small place to exhibit his books, and he doesn't have to show up.

Sentence 5:

Strength: The writer provides the sponsor an idea to promote airbrushing and his books. His idea may attract people to the exhibition.

Weakness: There are two errors in this sentence. The first one is that the writer should not use "neat". He can use "perfect" or "wonderful" instead. The second one is the "I" view in the sentence. All the writer thinks about are his own interest, and he neglects the reader's feeling.

Sentence 6:

Strength: The writer offers his airbrushing techniques and it may raise the reader's interest.

Weakness: The sentence is too long, and there are three clauses in one sentence. The sentence "I could demonstrate my techniques" sounds a little bit proud and arrogant. The writer should convey his message in another way.

Sentence 7:

Strength: Building up the writer's credibility by telling his related experience in airbrushing to the reader. In addition, the writer tells the reader that he has other books to promote.

Weakness: The writer still use "I" view in the sentence and it may make the writer boastful.

Sentence 8:

Weakness: The writer should avoid abbreviation, such as PR or PW. Reader cannot understand what the writer refers to since the abbreviations are the terms only used in the airbrushing field. Besides, the tone that the writer uses is proud and confident. The sponsor may think that he is slightly insulted by the writer's arrogant tone.

Sentence 9:

Weakness: It is inappropriate that the writer uses "you would like" in the sentence, because the form of "would like" is used to express one's modesty and politeness. As the writer requests for the chance to take part in the exhibition, it is the writer should be humble, not the reader (sponsor).

Revised Document

Dear Mr. Wilson:

I am a new publisher who wants to attend the bookseller's exhibition you sponsor this summer. I got this information from the announcement you posted in Publishers Weekly. Having great interest in this book exhibition, I would like to apply for one booth place to promote my two new books, T-shirt Art and How to Make Money in the Sign Painting Business.

As a publisher and an airbrush artist, I would like to do some airbrushing in the exhibition to attract more people to this activity. In addition, I have done hundreds of advertising illustrations.I believe that I am qualified to do this job. May I have the opportunity to introduce this meaningful book exhibition and the art of airbrushing to the public?

I will have a campaign in May, 2005. Meanwhile, I would like to post ads in Publishers Weekly and other art trade papers to promote this book exhibition and my new books. I am looking forward to take part in this book exhibition you hold. If you have made your decision, please let me know as soon as possible, so that I can arrange further information and proposal for you. I am glad to provide more details about this plan and myself. There are my biography and photos of myself attached to this letter, in case you have interest in my applying.

Sincerely,

Jeffrey Fishman

HOMEWORK 5 江則潔

Analyze This Document

The writer of this letter had clearly delivered the purpose and request. However, there are many impropriate sentences. The writer seems to overlook the benefit to the audience, instead; stress too much in the writer him or herself. Here, I assume this is a letter to a person or a company outside the writer's organization or which the writer unfamiliar with then I analyze the document sentence by sentence.

Sentence 1: the writer should give more detail of the books, for example, the type of the books, instead just saying "some great books."

Sentence 2: "I think it's a great idea." is impropriate here, the writer should transform this sentence into audience centered.

Sentence 3: this sentence should be immediately deleted. The writer should avoid informal tone.

Sentence 4: this sentence is, also, too impolite and self-centered.

Sentence 5 and 6: in these sentences, I don't see any thing relevant to this letter's goal. So if the writer wants to give the information anyway, the writer should show the benefit to the audience. Besides, the word "neat" shouldn't be used in the letter.

Sentence 7: I think "so I'll also be promoting my other book," is a weird sentence. It

should be "so I'll also promote my other book."

Sentence 8: I can't understand what PW is. The writer should not use abbreviation here.

Sentence 9 and 10: the writer should make these sentences more you attitude.

Sentence 11: the writer should not add personal feelings into the words.

In sum, the strength of this letter is its plain English and the weakness is the writer didn't use you attitude to enhance the credibility of the letter and the writer him or herself. In addition, the writer gave too mush information in one letter, therefore; the reader may be confused with the writer's purpose.

Revise Version

Dear Sir,

I am a new publisher with great interest in the bookseller's show in this summer (which) you announced in Publishers Weekly. Is there any other booth space you can offer? And I am look forward to learn more details about the show such as cost. It would be great if I can know it earlier.

I've been an advertising illustrator and sign painter, so the books I am going to promote will be about art, such as T-Shirt Art and How to Make Money in the Sign Painting Business. As an airbrush painter, I can demonstrate airbrush techniques to add some promoting activities in your exhibition.

You can contact me by this mail address. And I believe we can have a great time working together.

P.S. I have enclosed a biography and my photo, in case you need them.

Sincerely yours,

Bush Color

Homework5 49482055 Valentina

(1) Analyze the strengths and weaknesses

Sentence1

Strength:

Weakness: "really great books" is too abstract. The writer should let the receiver know what the books are about or what his intention is in the first sentence.

Sentence2

Strength: Telling the receiver where he saw the ad is good.

Weakness: "I think it's a great idea" is bad because no one asked the writer how the idea was.

Sentence3

Strength:

Weakness: "Count me in, folks!" This sentence is too informal for business letters.

Sentence4

Strength:

Weakness: "I would like to get some space to show my books" seems that the writer wants to order some fast food. The author should be politer by writing "I'm wondering if there are still any spare spaces".

Sentence5

Strength:

Weakness: 1. "neat" is too colloquial to be written in business letters.

2. The writer is too self-centered, he should be more reader benefit by telling the receiver that airbrushing show can attract more people to the fair instead of saying he wants to attract more audience to his stand.

Sentence6

Strength: Persuading the receiver that he can paint well is great ( eg. He was an airbrush artist…etc)

Weakness: Too self-centered. He shouldn't say that he can demonstrate his techniques.

Sentence7

Strength:

Weakness: The writer tells too much about himself. Therefore, it seems that he just want to brag himself instead of how much effort he can do to the receiver

Sentence8

Strength:

Weakness: The writer should avoid using abbreviation such as PR campaign and PW.

Sentence9

Strength: Giving the receiver some attachment is good because the receiver can know more about him.

Weakness:

Sentence10

Strength:

Weakness: The way he writes is too informal. He should say in a politer way. For example,"In order to prepare the expense in advance, will you please let me know how much it will be to be one of the exhibitors as soon as possible?" might be better.

(2)Revise the document

Dear Sir:

I am a start-up publisher who want join your book exhibition. I saw your announcement in Publisher Weekly about the booksellers' show. Therefore, I'm wondering if I can be one of the exhibitors to promote my new book, such as T-Shirt Art and How to Make Money in the Sign Painting Business. Because I was an airbrush artist, I can do some airbrushing on T-shirts live to attract more visitors to the book fair.

In case that you need to use my appearance there as part of your publicity, enclosed please find the information you may need (my photo, autobiography etc…)

Besides, as I've mentioned, I am a start-up publisher, so I don't know if my budget will be enough or not for the exhibition. In order to prepare the expense in advance, will you please let me know how much it will be to be one of the exhibitors as soon as possible? Thank you.

Best regards,

Valentina Hsiao

Homework 5 Traci

Analyze This Document p.97

(1) strengths and weaknesses

Sentence One
strength: Plain English.
weakness: The lack of supporting details besides "great" to
enhance credibility.

Sentence Two
strength: A warm conversational style which implies the
sender's intent of participation.
weakness: None.

Sentence Three
strength: A friendly conversational style.
weakness: A warm and still businesslike style is preferred.

Sentence Four
strength: Strong active voice for a request.
weakness: The casual and imprecise use of the word "get."

Sentence Five
strength: Concrete promotion idea offered.
weakness: The audience-centered method can be adopted here
by writing in terms of the audience's interests. And again,
the casual tone of the word "neat" is inappropriate in a
business letter.

Sentence Six
strength: Providing expertise to establish credibility and
thus building strong
relationship.
weakness: Slightly redundant. This sentence should be condensed.

Sentence Seven
strength: Also providing additional details for yet another
skill of the publisher and the related book.
weakness: In business letters, buzzwords should be avoided.
Bad content order; the information should be placed along
with the previous book information.

Sentence Eight
strength: Information regarding the promotion helps raise
interest and confidence in the books for the reader.
weakness: Abbreviation should be avoided for the clearness
of the letter unless it is very familiar to the reader. The
tone of "well known" needs revision.

Sentence Nine
strength: A considerate move showing the sender's enthusiasm
and boosting the feasibility of the deal.
weakness: Once again, the audience-centered method should be
adopted by offering the assistance in a humble tone.

Sentence Ten
strength: A forthright purpose expressed.
weakness: Putting important financial related message last.
The last sentence is unnecessary.

Overall Comment:
The strong point of the letter is that it is plain and clear
with an overall warm tone and
enough details to attract the reader's interest in doing the
business. However, poor
organization and the casual tone greatly diminishes the
credibility and competence of
the provided facts and the sender.

(2) revise the document

Dear Sir,
As a new publisher, I take great interest in the
bookseller's show announced in Publishers Weekly and would
like to inquire the rental fee for booth space to promote my
two new books, T-Shirt Art and How to Make Money in the Sign
Painting Business.
I plan to promote the books with ads in Publishers Weekly
and art trade papers in May 2005. I'd also very much like to
offer my appearance and air brushing skills live at the
bookseller's show. My biography and profile photo are enclosed.
Thank you very much for considering. I look forward to
hearing the show cost and details.

Yours truly,
Traci MacGrady

Homework 5 Sandy

49482037 Sandy

I. Analyze This Document
A new publisher who was eager to attend a book exhibition wrote this document. However, the messages could be more adapted to the audience. Here are some pros and cons of the document.

Sentence 1: Though the publisher did introduce him/herself, s/he did not reveal the main purpose at the beginning of the sentence. Neither did the writer establish the credibility of "really great books."

Sentence 2: The writer appreciated the concept of exhibition. Still, to establish the credibility, it would be better to point out how great the idea was. Separate the sentence would be more audience-centered.

Sentence 3: The writer pop out the main purpose of this document. Yet, the word "folks" did not maintain standards of etiquette, especially in a formal document. Soften the attitude would be better when asking someone for help.

Sentence 4: The publisher used plain English. Nevertheless, "you" attitude was not concerned. The receiver may be uncomfortable about the requirement.

Sentence 5: The writer started with a polite form "it would be...if I could...." Basically, airbrushing on T-shirts had nothing to do with book exhibition.

Sentence 6: Although the writer used time order to emphasize key thoughts; "demonstrating my techniques" made the receiver think that the writer was showing off. Audience could easily get the self and arrogant image of the writer.

Sentence 7: The writer used conversation tone. S/he gave audience the image that s/he joined exhibition only for promoting his/her own books. The concepts of "you" attitude and audience-centered were disrespected.

Sentence 8: The writer was confident in his/her performance. The writer should avoid abbreviations in a formal document. Eliminate sentences with showing off attitudes.

Sentence 9: Thinking your audience first was good, except it was related to your own publicity. Rewrite the sentence in an objective way.

Sentences 10: The sentence started with good manner "Please." Nevertheless, It was inappropriate to put money, the important issue in the end after the writer demanded so much. Formal document did not ends with P.S.

II. Rewrite

After the analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of each sentence, we can revise the document with more suitable context and attitude.

Dear My Friend,

I am here to ask you a favor. I would really appreciate if I have the opportunity to join your book exhibition. Being a new publisher, I can provide great books which I just imported recently. The book show is totally a great idea the moment I saw your announcement on the magazine. Please let me have the chance to share this honor. Since I am a new hand, there are many details I would like to ask you in advance.

First of all, I am wondering if there is extra space to present the books in a special way. Airbrushing on T-shirts can attract more people, and it also help promote our newly-released book, T-Shirt Art. I have been an airbrush artist before, so I think it's time to devote my contribution to our customers.

Secondly, we can offer our customers related books as one of our selling strategies. For example, we can put the book How to Make Money in the Sign Painting Business beside the previous T-Shirt Art . Publisher Weekly will introduce this book and held public relations in May, which the book will be well known by the time the show comes around in August. We can also promote books through related biography and photos.

Last but not least, please let me know the cost details for the exhibition. Since there are some economic problems, I would be thankful if I got your reply at your earliest convenience. Thank you.

Sincerely Yours,
Sandy Tsai

Homework5 Otto

Analyze This Document

1. Strengths and Weaknesses

After reading this document, I think this is a letter, written by a publisher, who is also as an author, to the receiver who is going to hold the bookseller's show this summer. The main goal of this letter is that the writer wants to know the costs for a booth space at the bookseller's show. The following are the strengths and weaknesses of each sentence.

(1). Strengths: The author uses plain English.

Weaknesses: It is not clear whether the author is asking for the cost or wants to sell books to the receiver.

(2). Strengths: The author appreciates the idea of the bookseller's show and lets them know their advertisement in Publishers Weekly was useful.

Weaknesses: The word "great" is vague.

(3). Strengths: This sentence makes the author and the receiver close.

Weaknesses: This sentence is informal and impolite by using colloquial language.

(4). Strengths: The author shows the goal simply and clearly in this sentence.

Weaknesses: It is too late to show the author's goal now.

(5). Strengths: The author is creative in using his or her creativity to promote the books.

Weaknesses: The word "neat" is vague and this sentence is irrelevant to the goal.

(6). Strengths: I think this sentence is persuasive because the author uses the experience to demonstrate credibility.

Weaknesses: This part should be introduced in the biography instead of in this letter.

(7). Strengths: It is a clear sentence for introducing the publisher and the books.

Weaknesses: It seems to be irrelevant to renting a booth space to sell books.

(8). Strengths: The publisher makes receivers know that he or she is confident and positive to promote the books so that these books sell well.

Weaknesses: It seems to be irrelevant to rent a booth space to sell books too.

(9). Strengths: The author is attentive by considering every possible way to promote the books.

Weaknesses: Not knowing about the receiver's preference on the author's books, the author need not enclose a biography and photo.

(10). Strengths: Points out the specific goal of this letter.

Weaknesses: I think this sentence, which is the goal of whole the letter, should not put in postscript.

(11). Strengths: The author reflects the feeling directly.

Weaknesses: It is irrelevant to the topic.

From the above strengths and weaknesses, we know that the publisher is confident. He or she is convinced the books can sell well. Unfortunately, the author did not pay attention to "you" view and ignored the main goal of the letter. The publisher mentions the books and the career backgrounds, but leaves the question of the cost of a booth space in postscript. Therefore, the entire letter seems to be irrelevant to the topic sentence and improper.

2. Revise this Document

Dear Sirs:

I am a new publisher who wants to attend your bookseller's show this summer, and I hope you can answer my questions: how much for a booth space costs a day and is there any other payment that should be paid.

I think that holding this kind of activity is great because it can help us publishers promote our sales volume and at the same time, can make your organization well-known. The announcement in Publishers Weekly about the bookseller's show is useful because this periodical is famous to booksellers. However, as publishers, we may want to know what the exact charge is because not all the publishers can afford to pay the rental expenses. That way, you may also realize what the publisher's aspirations caused by expenses are.

Besides, because I know that the restricted books are not allowed on public book fair, I would like to introduce my books briefly to let you know more clearly. My books are about arts and paintings. One of my books is called T-Shirt Art. It introduces doing airbrush art on T-shirts. Another one is How to Make Money in the Sign Painting Business. I, as an author, wrote this book to teach interested people to earn money with illustrations designing. Because the books are about arts and paintings which are general books suitable to all ages, it may also attract children and their parents to the show.

Thank you previously for answering my questions and I hope we can cooperate together in the future.

Yours sincerely,